Welcome to "Big Man in the Woods"!

I'm dedicated to helping Scout Leaders in England become exceptional Leaders. My channel offers valuable resources, advice, and inspiration to enhance your skills and create unforgettable camping experiences for your Scouts.

I try to provide practical tips, scout game ideas, and camping tricks tailored specifically for Scout Leaders. Led by an experienced Scout Leader with accolades such as the Medal of Merit and chief commendation, we bring firsthand knowledge and expertise to guide you. Join our community of passionate Scout Leaders who are committed to building essential skills and shaping the next generation of leaders. Subscribe to our channel for valuable content and engage in discussions. Let us help you become the best Scout Leader you can be in less than 200 words! https://www.bigmaninthewoods.co.uk/

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

A recent online discussion among Scout Leaders has sparked an interesting debate that goes to the heart of youth leadership, risk management, and trust in our young people. The question seems simple enough: should kitchen knives at scout camps be locked away overnight, just like axes and bushcraft knives?

What started as a straightforward query has revealed a fascinating divide in the scouting community, with passionate advocates on both sides presenting compelling arguments.

The “Lock Them Away” Camp

The security-conscious Scout Leaders make several strong points. One Scout Leader noted the practical concern: “I lock kitchen knives away at camp not because I don’t trust my guides but because there is always a risk of intruders. A small risk but one I couldn’t live with if something happened.”

This perspective emphasizes the “prevention is better than cure” philosophy. As another Scout Leader commented that recently his scout group purchased some lockable flight cases – one for bushcraft tools and another specifically for sharp kitchen equipment. The system they’ve developed is methodical: knives come out during meal prep, get color-coded by team, and are checked back in after washing up.

Some Scout Leaders have specific circumstances that inform their approach. One mentioned having “members in the unit at risk of self harm” a sobering reminder that our young people face challenges that previous generations of Scout Leaders might not have encountered as frequently.

The structured approach has its merits too. One group uses a system where scouts must ask for knives from a locked toolbox in the mess tent, use them under supervision, then return them after washing up. This creates accountability while maintaining security.

The “Trust Our Scouts” Perspective

On the other side, we have Scout Leaders who see the knife debate as part of a broader question about trust and youth development. One Canadian Scout Leader was particularly direct: “All of ours carry a knife on their belt, and presumably there’s a knife block in the kitchen at home – so no, no group feels the need to lock up all sharp objects. I really don’t think I’d take a group camping if they couldn’t be trusted to even have access to pointy things.”

The trust-based approach draws on decades of successful experience. One Scout Leader with over 40 years of experience reflected wistfully: “How life has changed! I would not have dreamt of taking away anything from our Guide or Scout patrols when I was a Scout Leader. They were all so very well trained.”

Several Scout Leaders pointed to their track records: “Over 90 years of our Troop and we have no record of anything approaching such an incident,” noted one veteran Scout Leader. Another echoed this sentiment: “In our Troop’s 90-year history it’s never been an issue, so my risk assessment is it’s a negligible risk to leave patrols in possession of kitchen knives.”

The philosophical argument runs deeper than mere statistics. As one Scout Leader observed: “A knife is a tool. Any tool could be used as a weapon. Once trained safely and to respect the rules, then… it shows trust in scouts/young people to do the right thing.”

The Middle Ground

Interestingly, several Scout Leaders have found compromise positions. Some distinguish between different age groups, with younger sections having cooking areas that are out of bounds unless supervised, while older, more experienced scouts get full access to patrol boxes.

Others focus on proper storage and training rather than locking away. These groups keep knives in sheaths or canvas knife rolls when not in use, and ensure that food preparation areas have clear boundaries and supervision protocols.

The Bigger Questions

This debate raises fascinating questions that extend far beyond knife management:

Risk Assessment vs. Development: How do we balance keeping young people safe with giving them opportunities to develop responsibility and independence?

Trust and Training: If we’ve trained our scouts properly, shouldn’t we trust them with the tools they need? Or does proper training include teaching when tools should and shouldn’t be accessible?

Changing Times: Have the challenges facing young people changed so significantly that traditional approaches need updating? Or are we over-complicating simple issues?

Consistency: If we lock away axes and bushcraft knives, why would kitchen knives be different? One Scout Leader posed the pointed question: “Do you lock all the personal cutlery knives and forks and spoons?”

The Risk Assessment Reality

Perhaps the most telling comment came from a Scout Leader who said: “They are locked away, but please don’t find more things to risk assess. I spend more time on these now than I do on the camp.”

This highlights a genuine tension in modern scouting leadership. The administrative burden of comprehensive risk assessment can sometimes feel like it’s overwhelming the actual business of youth development.

One Scout Leader challenged the group directly: “What exactly are you all afraid of?” while another responded pragmatically: “Not afraid of anything, it’s called being risk aware and being prepared.”

Finding Balance

The truth is, both sides make valid points. The security-conscious Scout Leaders aren’t wrong to consider all potential risks, especially when they have specific circumstances (like members at risk of self-harm) that require extra precautions. The trust-based Scout Leaders aren’t naive – they’re drawing on decades of successful experience and a philosophy that sees challenge and responsibility as essential to youth development.

Perhaps the real lesson here is that there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Each group needs to consider their specific circumstances: the age and experience of their members, their camping environment, their group culture, and their Scout Leaders’ comfort levels.

What’s encouraging is that both approaches seem to work well for their respective groups. The key appears to be intentionality – whether you lock knives away or leave them accessible, having a clear policy that your leadership team understands and implements consistently seems more important than which specific approach you choose.

The debate also serves as a healthy reminder that good Scout Leaders regularly question their assumptions and practices. Sometimes that leads to changes, and sometimes it reinforces why you do things the way you do – but either way, it keeps us thinking critically about how we serve our young people.

In the end, whether your kitchen knives spend the night locked in a toolbox or sleeping peacefully in a patrol box, what matters most is that you’ve thought carefully about your approach and can explain your reasoning to parents, other Scout Leaders, and most importantly, to your scouts themselves.